When Official Stories in Comoros Fell Apart
Comoros does not have a well-documented tradition of spectacular newspaper monsters, forged fossils or famous photographic hoaxes.
Page outline Jump by section
Introduction
The passport affair is the central case because the deception operated through genuine state documents. Comorian citizenship was presented differently to different audiences: as foreign investment to legislators, as a solution for stateless Gulf residents to overseas governments, and as a valuable second identity to private buyers. A later parliamentary inquiry alleged systematic fraud, unauthorised passport production and falsified records. Yet the resulting prosecutions remain politically contested, so the scandal should not be reduced to a simple tale of criminals exposed by an impartial system.[reuters.com]reuters.comComoros passport scheme was unlawful, abused by "mafiaComoros passport scheme was unlawful, abused by "mafia…March 24, 2018 — 24 Mar 2018 — A programme to sell Comoros Islands citiz…
The passport scheme that sold several different stories
In 2008, Comoros adopted an “economic citizenship” programme. The public promise was attractive to a small state with limited resources: foreign money would be raised by granting citizenship, and that money would support national development. The arrangement was promoted domestically as a route to investment from wealthy Gulf countries. In practice, it became connected to plans involving stateless people in Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates, as well as private purchasers who had no meaningful connection to Comoros.[Reuters]reuters.comComoros passport scheme was unlawful, abused by "mafiaComoros passport scheme was unlawful, abused by "mafia…March 24, 2018 — 24 Mar 2018 — A programme to sell Comoros Islands citiz…
This was not simply a case of forged booklets made in a back room. Many of the passports were physically authentic documents produced through official or semi-official channels. The alleged fraud lay in who was entitled to receive them, which authorisations were genuine, how many were produced, where the money went and whether state records accurately reflected the transactions.
That distinction matters. A convincing counterfeit imitates a real passport. In the Comorian affair, a real passport could embody a false administrative story: that its holder had been lawfully naturalised, that the proper fee had reached the treasury, or that the document had been issued for the purpose recorded in government files.
A nationality designed for people who would not live there
One important market was the Gulf’s stateless population, commonly known as the Bidoon. Kuwait explored giving some of its stateless residents Comorian citizenship rather than fully incorporating them as Kuwaiti citizens. The attraction was bureaucratic: a person classified as a foreign national could be treated differently from someone officially recorded as stateless.
The proposed Comorian identity did not necessarily involve migration to the islands, knowledge of the country or participation in its civic life. It functioned largely as a documentary nationality. Critics therefore saw it as an attempt to move a difficult citizenship problem from one country’s records into another’s, without resolving the affected people’s insecure status. The proposed mass arrangement with Kuwait drew public criticism and was not completed as initially envisaged, although Comorian citizenship documents were issued to people elsewhere in the Gulf.[Wikipedia]WikipediaComoros passport sales scandalComoros passport sales scandal
The episode is sometimes described too loosely as the sale of “fake passports”. That wording can be misleading. Some recipients possessed genuine Comorian documents but lacked a substantial relationship with Comoros. The more precise question is whether their naturalisation was lawful, properly recorded and consistent with the purpose Parliament had been given when approving the scheme.
How the official programme allegedly became a hidden market
The first warning sign was the gap between the programme’s stated purpose and its later reach. A Comorian parliamentary investigation concluded that passports had been issued far beyond the approved arrangements with Gulf governments. It alleged that unofficial networks had sold thousands of documents and that as much as US$100 million in expected revenue had disappeared. Investigators also reported an extraordinary number of diplomatic passports, including documents granted to people who were not Comorian officials.[Reuters]reuters.comComoros passport scheme was unlawful, abused by "mafiaComoros passport scheme was unlawful, abused by "mafia…March 24, 2018 — 24 Mar 2018 — A programme to sell Comoros Islands citiz…
Reuters separately examined presidential decrees, passport records and lists of recipients. Its investigation found that Comorian passports had been obtained by numerous Iranian nationals, including executives in industries affected by international sanctions. More than 100 of the 155 passport holders whose documents Comoros cancelled in early 2018 were Iranian, according to the records reviewed. Some individuals had acquired more than one Comorian passport. Officials feared that the additional nationality could help holders travel, open accounts or conduct business with less obvious exposure to restrictions attached to Iranian identities.[Reuters]reuters.comThey included seniorAs sanctions bit, Iranian executives bought African passports29 Jun 2018 — Reuters found that more than 100 of 155 people who had…
The documents were valuable precisely because Comoros was not the centre of international attention. A passport from a small state could appear less conspicuous than one from a heavily sanctioned country. This was an exploitation of institutional trust: border officers, banks and commercial partners normally presume that a government has verified the identity and status printed in its documents.
The affair also demonstrates why authentic materials do not guarantee an authentic transaction. The printing company, official seals and government decrees could all give the process an appearance of legitimacy. Investigators therefore had to reconstruct the chain behind each document:
- Was there a valid naturalisation decision?
- Did the named official have authority to approve it?
- Did the passport number appear in the proper register?
- Was the declared payment actually received by the state?
- Had records been altered or created after the event?
- Was a diplomatic title genuine or merely purchased?
This kind of fraud is harder to recognise than a crude forgery because every individual component may look official.
What exposed the scheme
The passport affair unravelled through institutional records rather than a single dramatic confession. Changes in government brought renewed scrutiny, while concerns from Gulf partners and foreign security officials increased pressure for an investigation. Comoros cancelled improperly issued passports, and a parliamentary commission examined decrees, payment records, production arrangements and the number of documents issued.[Reuters]reuters.comComoros says abuse of passports-for-cash scheme worries…20 Jan 2018 — Comoros recently cancelled 170 passports that the governm…
The inquiry alleged systematic fraud and recommended action against senior political figures and businesspeople associated with the programme. Investigators also focused on the Belgian company Semlex, which supplied Comorian biometric documents. Belgian police searched Semlex premises in 2018 in an investigation concerning possible corruption and money laundering; the company and its representatives denied wrongdoing in reporting on the wider affair.[Reuters]reuters.comafrica passports karaziwanHow to make millions selling passports to Africa22 Dec 2017 — Reuters determined that at least two buyers of Comoros passports are…
Former president Ahmed Abdallah Sambi and associates were later charged with offences connected to the programme, including corruption, embezzlement and falsification of records. In November 2022, a Comorian state security court convicted Sambi of high treason and sentenced him to life imprisonment. Former vice-president Mohamed Ali Soilihi and businessman Bashar Kiwan also received sentences.[Al Jazeera]aljazeera.comAl Jazeera Ex-Comoros president given life sentence over passportAl Jazeera Ex-Comoros president given life sentence over passport
The convictions did not settle every question. Sambi denied wrongdoing, boycotted the proceedings and argued that the court could not provide a fair trial. His lawyers characterised the prosecution as unlawful, while supporters viewed the case through the country’s intense political rivalries. It is therefore possible to accept the strong documentary evidence that the citizenship system was gravely abused without assuming that every allegation, financial estimate or judicial decision is beyond dispute.[citizenshiprightsafrica.org]citizenshiprightsafrica.orgcomoros ex president says innocent of charges against him on passports schemecomoros ex president says innocent of charges against him on passports scheme
Fake local voices in the 2019 political climate
A different form of deception appeared around the 2019 Comorian presidential election. The Digital Forensic Research Lab identified a Tunisia-based influence network linked to the communications company UReputation. The wider operation, later called Operation Carthage, targeted several French-speaking African countries, including Comoros.[Medium]medium.comDFRLab uncovers Tunisia-based political influenceDFRLab uncovers Tunisia-based political influence
The network did not depend on one spectacular false story. Its method was to manufacture the appearance of independent, local political conversation. Fake accounts posed as residents, while pages presented themselves as news organisations or community forums. The same operators could publish material, endorse it through other controlled accounts and direct readers towards associated websites. This made promoted narratives look as though they had arisen naturally within the country being targeted.
Meta removed 446 Facebook pages, 182 accounts, 96 groups, 60 events and 209 Instagram accounts associated with the Tunisia-based operation as a whole. The company said the operators concealed their identities, masqueraded as local people and managed pages posing as independent news outlets. Comoros was one of several countries in the network’s field of activity, so those totals should not be mistaken for Comoros-only figures.[About Facebook]about.fb.commay cib reportmay cib report
The campaign illustrates “coordinated inauthentic behaviour”: deception about who is speaking and how apparently separate voices are connected. A post need not be entirely false for the operation to be misleading. Genuine news, partisan interpretation and unsupported allegations can be mixed together, while hidden coordination creates a false impression of popularity or consensus.
The exposure came from digital traces rather than traditional fact-checking alone. Investigators compared page administrators, posting patterns, advertising activity, linked websites and repeated content. The important evidence was not merely whether one article contained an error, but whether supposedly unrelated outlets were being operated by the same concealed organisation.
When origin legends are not straightforward hoaxes
Comoros also has celebrated stories about its early rulers, the arrival of Islam and migration from Persia. These deserve careful treatment because oral tradition is not automatically fraud. A legend may preserve social memory, express political legitimacy or connect a community with a wider religious world without having been invented as a conscious attempt to deceive.
Across the Swahili coast and Comoros, prominent families and towns have claimed descent from migrants associated with Shiraz in Persia. Earlier scholarship sometimes treated such accounts as records of foreign founders who brought civilisation to an African coast. Later historians and archaeologists argued that many of these genealogies worked as status claims: they connected local elites to prestigious centres of Islam and Indian Ocean commerce while understating the deep African foundations of coastal societies.[jstor.org]jstor.orgThe Shirazi in Swahili Traditions, Culture, and HistoryThe Shirazi in Swahili Traditions, Culture, and History
Archaeology has complicated both the literal legend and the strongest sceptical reaction to it. Excavations show that the Comoros belonged to extensive Indian Ocean trading networks and received ceramics, crops and other influences from distant regions. Research on early plant remains found a striking presence of Asian crops, while archaeological work at sites such as Dembeni demonstrates substantial trade with the Persian Gulf and Red Sea worlds.[mpg.de]shh.mpg.deOpen source on mpg.de.
This evidence does not prove every royal genealogy or tale of a founding Persian prince. Nor does it support an older picture in which outsiders simply created coastal civilisation. It points instead to local African communities participating in long-distance migration, marriage, commerce and religious change. Some claimed ancestries may contain fragments of real contact while arranging them into politically useful family stories.
A similar caution applies to the tradition of Mtswa-Mwindza, a ruler said to have travelled to Mecca in Islam’s earliest period and returned to establish the faith in Comoros. Scholars once rejected the story’s chronology, while excavations at the associated mosque site have prompted renewed argument about how early the structure and local Islamic presence may be. The archaeological evidence can test dates and buildings, but it cannot by itself verify every biographical detail preserved in oral tradition.[UDSM Journals]journals.udsm.ac.tzOpen source on udsm.ac.tz.
Calling such traditions “hoaxes” would flatten the distinction between forgery and cultural memory. The useful sceptical question is not simply “Did this happen exactly as told?” It is also “When was this version recorded, whose authority did it support, and which parts can independent evidence confirm?”
Why these stories remain persuasive
The major Comorian cases worked because they borrowed credibility from trusted forms.
The passport scheme borrowed the authority of the state. A professionally printed identity document seemed to guarantee that the citizenship behind it had been lawfully granted. The social-media operation borrowed the familiar appearance of local journalism and ordinary political discussion. Historical genealogies borrowed the prestige of sacred geography, aristocratic descent and the Indian Ocean’s real record of migration and trade.
Each case also offered a benefit:
- Political leaders could promise investment without raising taxes.
- Brokers could earn money from access to citizenship documents.
- Foreign buyers could acquire a more convenient international identity.
- Gulf authorities could recategorise stateless residents without granting them full local citizenship.
- Political consultants could make sponsored narratives appear locally popular.
- Elite families could strengthen claims to rank through prestigious ancestry.
Exposure required looking behind appearances. Investigators followed payments, passport registers and presidential decrees; digital researchers mapped shared account control and advertising; archaeologists compared oral accounts with dated material remains. In every case, the decisive question was provenance: where did the document, voice or story come from, and can its claimed origin be independently demonstrated?
What Comoros adds to the history of deception
Comoros shows that consequential deception need not involve an invented monster or an obviously forged photograph. A genuine passport can carry a questionable legal identity. A real news article can be promoted by fake local personalities. A meaningful tradition can be mistaken for a literal transcript of the distant past.
The country’s best-documented cases also warn against easy endings. The passport scandal produced investigations and convictions, but disputes over political motivation and due process remain. Operation Carthage was dismantled on major platforms, yet the broader business of disguised political promotion persists well beyond one network. Archaeology has overturned simplistic accounts of Persian founders without reducing Comorian history to an equally simplistic story of isolation.
The common thread is not national credulity. It is the power of official symbols, media appearances and prestigious ancestry to make claims feel credible before their provenance has been checked. In Comoros, as elsewhere, the most durable deceptions have succeeded by attaching themselves to something real: a government’s authority, a recognisable news format, or genuine centuries of movement across the Indian Ocean.
Amazon book picks
Further Reading
Books and field guides related to When Official Stories in Comoros Fell Apart. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.
The Dictator's Handbook
Explains incentives behind political narratives, patronage and governance scandals.
Why Nations Fail
Useful framework for understanding state capacity and accountability.
African Politics in Comparative Perspective
Offers regional context for political legitimacy and contested narratives.
eBay marketplace picks
Marketplace Samples
Live-tested eBay searches with available results related to this page.
Endnotes
1.
Source: reuters.com
Title: Comoros passport scheme was unlawful, abused by “mafia
Link:https://www.reuters.com/article/world/comoros-passport-scheme-was-unlawful-abused-by-mafia-networks-report-idUSKBN1GZ37H/
Source snippet
Comoros passport scheme was unlawful, abused by "mafia...March 24, 2018 — 24 Mar 2018 — A programme to sell Comoros Islands citiz...
Published: March 24, 2018
2.
Source: reuters.com
Title: They included senior
Link:https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/iran-passports-comoros/
Source snippet
As sanctions bit, Iranian executives bought African passports29 Jun 2018 — Reuters found that more than 100 of 155 people who had...
3.
Source: reuters.com
Title: africa passports karaziwan
Link:https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/africa-passports-karaziwan/
Source snippet
How to make millions selling passports to Africa22 Dec 2017 — Reuters determined that at least two buyers of Comoros passports are...
4.
Source: reuters.com
Link:https://www.reuters.com/article/business/comoros-says-abuse-of-passports-for-cash-scheme-worries-gulf-allies-idUSKBN1FA02L/
Source snippet
Comoros says abuse of passports-for-cash scheme worries...20 Jan 2018 — Comoros recently cancelled 170 passports that the governm...
5.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: Comoros passport sales scandal
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comoros_passport_sales_scandal
6.
Source: medium.com
Title: DFRLab uncovers Tunisia-based political influence
Link:https://medium.com/dfrlab/dfrlab-uncovers-tunisia-based-political-influence-operation-on-facebook-8c4d16b90744
7.
Source: jstor.org
Title: The Shirazi in Swahili Traditions, Culture, and History
Link:https://www.jstor.org/stable/3171638
8.
Source: cambridge.org
Link:https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/history-in-africa/article/oral-historiography-and-the-shirazi-of-the-east-african-coast/E7961C092A5BB79E1DDB7BEFB919EB20
9.
Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/344292325_Islamic_Archaeology_in_the_Comoros_The_Swahili_and_the_Rock_Crystal_Trade_with_the_Abbasid_and_Fatimid_Caliphates
10.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: List of fake news websites
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fake_news_websites
11.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: Archaeological forgery
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archaeological_forgery
12.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: Shirazi people
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shirazi_people
13.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: History of the Comoros
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Comoros
14.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/groups/kallkritik/posts/1061252177732321/
15.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/Malaysiakini/posts/every-time-prime-minister-anwar-ibrahim-posts-on-facebook-his-comment-section-fl/1268649655300411/
16.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/News3LasVegas/posts/facebook-said-tuesday-it-has-removed-hundreds-of-fake-accounts-linked-to-an-iran/3814065998647781/
17.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/groups/twigf/posts/3685532821690026/
18.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/kinitv/posts/every-time-prime-minister-anwar-ibrahim-posts-on-facebook-the-comments-are-flood/1345792484258022/
19.
Source: facebook.com
Title: our commitment to safety
Link:https://www.facebook.com/business/news/our-commitment-to-safety
20.
Source: facebook.com
Title: the comoros islands began selling passports in 2008 as a means to raise much nee
Link:https://www.facebook.com/Reuters/posts/the-comoros-islands-began-selling-passports-in-2008-as-a-means-to-raise-much-nee/1964653850221628/
21.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/mic.gov.sl/posts/investigation-of-alleged-misuse-of-diplomatic-passport/1137511798498715/
22.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/groups/zoroastrianheritage/posts/2288084924578106/
23.
Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/395753064_Coordinated_inauthentic_behaviour_on_Facebook_A_typology_of_manufactured_attention
24.
Source: transparency.meta.com
Title: inauthentic behavior
Link:https://transparency.meta.com/policies/community-standards/inauthentic-behavior/
25.
Source: reuters.com
Title: comoros seeks us interpol help to vet buyers of comoros passports id USKBN1EL1OH
Link:https://www.reuters.com/article/us-africa-passports-comoros/comoros-seeks-us-interpol-help-to-vet-buyers-of-comoros-passports-idUSKBN1EL1OH/
26.
Source: medium.com
Link:https://medium.com/dfrlab/top-takes-suspected-russian-intelligence-operation-39212367d2f0
27.
Source: 2017-2021.state.gov
Title: passport and visa fraud
Link:https://2017-2021.state.gov/passport-and-visa-fraud/
28.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Ex-Comoros president Sambi charged over passport scheme
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AMTN4xjqfgY
Source snippet
Wikipedia...
29.
Source: citizenshiprightsafrica.org
Title: comoros ex president says innocent of charges against him on passports scheme
Link:https://citizenshiprightsafrica.org/en/comoros-ex-president-says-innocent-of-charges-against-him-on-passports-scheme/
30.
Source: voanews.com
Link:https://www.voanews.com/a/comoros-security-court-sentences-ex-president-to-life-in-prison-/6853139.html
Source snippet
Voice of AmericaComoros Security Court Sentences Ex-President to Life in...28 Nov 2022 — Sambi is charged with treason and the court sai...
31.
Source: aljazeera.com
Title: comoros passports abused by mafia networks
Link:https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/3/24/comoros-passports-abused-by-mafia-networks
32.
Source: aljazeera.com
Title: Al Jazeera Ex-Comoros president given life sentence over passport
Link:https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/11/28/ex-comoros-president-given-life-sentence-over-passport-scandal
33.
Source: seychellesnewsagency.com
Link:https://www.seychellesnewsagency.com/public/articles/17778/comoros-ex-leader-refuses-to-attend-high-treason-trial
34.
Source: about.fb.com
Title: may cib report
Link:https://about.fb.com/news/2020/06/may-cib-report/
35.
Source: shh.mpg.de
Link:https://www.shh.mpg.de/308075/Boivin-Archaeology-of-the-Comoros
36.
Source: journals.udsm.ac.tz
Link:https://journals.udsm.ac.tz/index.php/sap/article/view/88/80
37.
Source: pieterderideaux.jimdofree.com
Link:https://pieterderideaux.jimdofree.com/comoros/
38.
Source: journal.equinoxpub.com
Link:https://journal.equinoxpub.com/JIA/article/view/12854
39.
Source: journal.equinoxpub.com
Link:https://journal.equinoxpub.com/JIA/article/view/25865
40.
Source: journals.udsm.ac.tz
Link:https://journals.udsm.ac.tz/index.php/sap/article/view/88
41.
Source: citizenshiprightsafrica.org
Title: comoros passport scheme was unlawful abused by mafia networks report
Link:https://citizenshiprightsafrica.org/en/comoros-passport-scheme-was-unlawful-abused-by-mafia-networks-report/
42.
Source: citizenshiprightsafrica.org
Title: comoros seeks us interpol help to vet buyers of comoros passports
Link:https://citizenshiprightsafrica.org/en/comoros-seeks-us-interpol-help-to-vet-buyers-of-comoros-passports/
43.
Source: dfrlab.org
Title: DFR Lab
Link:https://dfrlab.org/
44.
Source: dfrlab.org
Title: project muga
Link:https://dfrlab.org/2024/12/20/project-muga/
45.
Source: dfrlab.org
Link:https://dfrlab.org/2023/12/13/how-foreign-actors-targeted-polish-information-environment-ahead-of-parliamentary-elections/
46.
Source: africanarchaeology.org
Link:https://www.africanarchaeology.org/comoros-1
47.
Source: about.fb.com
Title: october 2020 cib report
Link:https://about.fb.com/news/2020/11/october-2020-cib-report/
Published: october 2020
Additional References
48.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Ex-Comoros President Sambi will still remain in detention- Prosecutor
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BDiK3hZQrj0
Source snippet
Treason Charges: Detained Former President Of Comoros, Ahmed Abdallah Sambi, Faces Trial...
49.
Source: arxiv.org
Link:https://arxiv.org/html/2401.02095v1
50.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Comoros court sentences former president Sambi to life in prison
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D-O9DapCTIQ
Source snippet
Ex-Comoros president Sambi charged over passport scheme...
51.
Source: youtube.com
Title: What Happened to Comoros Citizenship by Investment?
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=byqhFE6ellc
Source snippet
Comoros court sentences former president Sambi to life in prison...
52.
Source: atlanticcouncil.org
Link:https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/operation-carthage-002.pdf
53.
Source: confinity.com
Link:https://www.confinity.com/countries/comoros
54.
Source: liverpoolmuseums.org.uk
Link:https://www.liverpoolmuseums.org.uk/stories/debunking-six-archaeology-myths
55.
Source: icc-cpi.int
Link:https://www.icc-cpi.int/court-record/icc-01/13-34
56.
Source: mobilemarketingmagazine.com
Link:https://mobilemarketingmagazine.com/facebook-shuts-down-influence-campaigns-linked-to-saudi-government-uae-and-egypt/
57.
Source: africacheck.org
Link:https://africacheck.org/third-party-fact-checks
Topic Tree
Follow this branch
Related pages 192
- Albanian Hoaxes
- Algerian Hoaxes
- Antigua Deceptions
- Argentina Hoaxes
- Armenian Hoaxes
- +187 more in sidebar