Branchoria Historical Mysteries by Country Historical Mysteries by Country

Compare strange historical mysteries and unresolved enigmas across countries.

Within Malta Mysteries

Were St Paul's Lost Anchors Really Found?

Roman-era anchors recovered near Malta cannot be securely tied to St Paul, yet uncertain provenance allowed a possible relic to become a persuasive attraction.

On this page

  • The rival shipwreck location near St Thomas Bay
  • Why Roman anchors cannot identify one famous vessel
  • How faith, tourism and uncertain provenance reinforced the claim
Preview for Were St Paul's Lost Anchors Really Found?

Introduction

Were St Paul’s lost anchors really found? The short answer is no one knows. Malta’s Christian identity is closely tied to the New Testament account of Paul’s shipwreck on the island around AD 60, but no surviving artefact can be securely connected to that voyage. Over the years, Roman anchors recovered from Maltese waters have been presented by some writers, divers and religious enthusiasts as possible remains of Paul’s vessel. Yet archaeologists face a basic problem: an anchor can often be dated to a broad period, but it cannot normally be linked to one specific ship without exceptional supporting evidence. As a result, the story of “St Paul’s anchors” sits in the grey area between archaeology, tradition, tourism and faith rather than established historical fact.[CBN]cbn.comApostle Paul's Shipwreck: A Tale of Four Anchors | CBN NewsToday the anchors are tucked away in the corner of Valletta's Maritime Muse…

Paul s Anchors illustration 1

In Malta’s wider history of disputed relics and contested discoveries, the anchor claims are a useful example of how genuine artefacts can acquire far larger stories than the evidence alone can support.

The Rival Shipwreck Location Near St Thomas Bay

For centuries, Maltese tradition associated Paul’s shipwreck with St Paul’s Bay in the north of Malta. In the early twenty-first century, however, alternative theories gained publicity by arguing that the biblical description in Acts 27 matched St Thomas Bay on the island’s south-eastern coast more closely.[The Malta Independent]independent.com.mtThe Malta IndependentSt Paul's Shipwreck: St Paul's Bay or St Thomas Bay?25 Apr 2010 — According to Mr Cornuke, St Paul was shipwrecked i…

The most influential modern advocate of this view was American explorer Robert Cornuke, who argued that geographical details in the biblical text pointed to a reef near St Thomas Bay. His case attracted attention because Acts mentions four anchors being dropped from the stern before the ship ran aground. Cornuke and supporters claimed that Roman anchor stocks found offshore matched this unusual detail.[biblearchaeology.org]biblearchaeology.orgThomas Bay (Acts 27:39Associates For Biblical ResearchDoes 'The Lost Shipwreck Of Paul' Hold Water?Cornuke claims to have found the only tangible remains from…

The argument sounded persuasive to many readers because it appeared to combine scripture, underwater archaeology and a tangible discovery. If four anchors were mentioned in the text and several ancient anchors were found nearby, the connection seemed obvious. Yet critics noted that the evidence was circumstantial. The anchors were not excavated as part of a documented archaeological investigation tied to a specific wreck site, and no associated ship remains were recovered that could identify the vessel.[Associates For Biblical Research]biblearchaeology.orgThomas Bay (Acts 27:39Associates For Biblical ResearchDoes 'The Lost Shipwreck Of Paul' Hold Water?Cornuke claims to have found the only tangible remains from…

As a result, the debate became less about a particular anchor and more about competing interpretations of where the shipwreck occurred at all.

ST. PAUL'S SHIPWRECK FOUND?

Channel: gtasoul

Open on YouTube

Why Roman Anchors Cannot Identify One Famous Vessel

The weakness in the claim is not that the anchors are fake. The anchors themselves are real ancient objects. The problem is attribution.[CBN]cbn.comApostle Paul's Shipwreck: A Tale of Four Anchors | CBN NewsToday the anchors are tucked away in the corner of Valletta's Maritime Muse…

Roman-period ships crossed Maltese waters for centuries. Merchants, naval vessels and fishing craft all used anchors broadly similar in form. Finding a Roman anchor near Malta therefore demonstrates ancient maritime activity, but not the identity of a particular ship. Archaeologists generally require a much stronger chain of evidence before assigning an artefact to a famous historical event.[HolyLandPhotos' Blog]holylandphotos.wordpress.comIn this temporary “home” 11 Anchor Stocks were collected.Read moreHolyLandPhotos' BlogPaul's Shipwreck on Malta: Anchor Stocks—Part 1Dec 22, 2021 — Temporary “home” for the Roman Anchor Stocks that are i…

Several factors complicate the matter:

  • Ancient anchors were frequently lost, discarded or reused.
  • Underwater finds are often moved by currents, storms or later human activity.
  • Many Roman vessels travelled through the same sea routes.
  • No inscription naming Paul, his companions or the vessel has been discovered.
  • No securely documented wreck assemblage has been found that can be linked to the voyage described in Acts.[biblearchaeology.org]biblearchaeology.orgThomas Bay (Acts 27:39Associates For Biblical ResearchDoes 'The Lost Shipwreck Of Paul' Hold Water?Cornuke claims to have found the only tangible remains from…

This is why even researchers interested in locating Paul’s shipwreck generally describe the anchor evidence as suggestive rather than conclusive. The artefacts may be ancient and may come from the correct era, but that is not enough to identify one ship among countless others that sailed the Mediterranean.[Associates For Biblical Research]biblearchaeology.orgThomas Bay (Acts 27:39Associates For Biblical ResearchDoes 'The Lost Shipwreck Of Paul' Hold Water?Cornuke claims to have found the only tangible remains from…

Paul s Anchors illustration 2

How Faith, Tourism and Uncertain Provenance Reinforced the Claim

The appeal of the anchor story rests partly on Malta’s unique relationship with Paul. The shipwreck narrative is not merely a biblical episode on the island; it forms a foundational element of Maltese Christian heritage. A physical object supposedly connected to that event therefore carries enormous symbolic value.[Aleteia]aleteia.orgThe wreckage that made a nation: StPaul's shipwreck - Aleteia10 Feb 2025 — Built in the 1570s, the church houses relics such as part of Paul's right wrist bone and a marble…

Tourism also plays a role. Visitors often hope to encounter tangible links to famous events described in scripture. A Roman anchor displayed in a museum is interesting. An anchor that might have belonged to Paul’s ship is far more compelling. The uncertainty itself becomes part of the attraction.[CBN]cbn.comApostle Paul's Shipwreck: A Tale of Four Anchors | CBN NewsToday the anchors are tucked away in the corner of Valletta's Maritime Muse…

The process resembles many disputed relic traditions elsewhere in Europe. A genuine ancient object is discovered. Its exact origin is unclear. A famous historical or religious event provides a possible explanation. Repetition through books, lectures, documentaries and travel literature gradually turns a possibility into something that sounds like established fact.[Associates For Biblical Research]biblearchaeology.orgThomas Bay (Acts 27:39Associates For Biblical ResearchDoes 'The Lost Shipwreck Of Paul' Hold Water?Cornuke claims to have found the only tangible remains from…

That does not necessarily mean deliberate deception occurred. In many cases, promoters sincerely believe the connection. The issue is that confidence can grow faster than the evidence.

Where was Paul shipwrecked on his way to Rome?

Channel: Drive Thru History with Dave Stotts

Open on YouTube

The Wider Question of St Paul Relics in Malta

The anchor debate exists alongside other relic claims associated with Paul in Malta. The Collegiate Parish Church of St Paul’s Shipwreck in Valletta preserves a relic identified as part of the apostle’s right wrist bone and a marble fragment traditionally linked to his martyrdom in Rome. These objects are important devotional relics within Catholic tradition and have long histories of ecclesiastical custody.[sanctipauli.mt]sanctipauli.mtOpen source on sanctipauli.mt.

However, from a historical perspective, proving the authenticity of relics associated with first-century figures is extremely difficult. The chain of custody usually depends on centuries of religious tradition rather than modern archaeological documentation.[Atlas Obscura]atlasobscura.comof shipwrecks and wristbones the story of st paul s remainsof shipwrecks and wristbones the story of st paul s remains

This distinction matters because discussions of relics often involve two different standards of evidence. Religious significance may rest on faith, continuity of devotion and church tradition. Historical authentication depends on documentary, archaeological and scientific proof. The debate over the anchors illustrates what happens when those standards overlap but do not fully coincide.

Paul s Anchors illustration 3

What the Anchor Controversy Reveals

The story of St Paul’s anchors is not a classic hoax involving forged artefacts or fabricated discoveries. Instead, it is a case of uncertain provenance becoming attached to a powerful narrative. Real Roman anchors were found. A genuine biblical shipwreck tradition exists. The leap occurs when those separate facts are fused into a confident claim that the anchors came from Paul’s vessel.[cbn.com]cbn.comApostle Paul's Shipwreck: A Tale of Four Anchors | CBN NewsToday the anchors are tucked away in the corner of Valletta's Maritime Muse…

For historians and archaeologists, the lesson is straightforward: artefacts gain meaning from context, not simply age. Without a securely documented wreck site and supporting evidence, Roman anchors remain Roman anchors. They may be connected to Paul’s voyage, but no available evidence proves that they are.

For Malta, the episode demonstrates how national memory, religious identity and archaeological uncertainty can combine to create enduring stories. The anchors continue to attract attention not because the case is settled, but because it remains tantalisingly unresolved.[cbn.com]cbn.comApostle Paul's Shipwreck: A Tale of Four Anchors | CBN NewsToday the anchors are tucked away in the corner of Valletta's Maritime Muse…

The Lost Shipwreck of Paul

Channel: Titanic Films by Mark

Open on YouTube

Amazon book picks

Further Reading

Books and field guides related to Were St Paul's Lost Anchors Really Found?. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.

BookCover for Paul

Paul

By N. T. Wright

First published 2019. Subjects: Paul, the apostle, saint, Bible, biography, o. t., Civilization.

See on Amazon
Browse more on Amazon:Were St biographyThe Acts of the ApostlesPaul

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

eBay marketplace picks

Marketplace Samples

Live-tested eBay searches with available results related to this page.

UsingUSA
Browse more oneBay.co.uk

Example items shown for inspiration; availability and pricing can change. Branchoria may earn a commission if you purchase through outbound eBay links.

Endnotes

1. Source: cbn.com
Link:https://cbn.com/news/world/apostle-pauls-shipwreck-tale-four-anchors

Source snippet

Apostle Paul's Shipwreck: A Tale of Four Anchors | CBN NewsToday the anchors are tucked away in the corner of Valletta's Maritime Muse...

2. Source: lifeandland.org
Link:https://www.lifeandland.org/category/pauls-shipwreck-on-malta/

Source snippet

Paul's Shipwreck on Malta | Life and LandIn the video he located old divers and spear fisherman on the island who claimed they found four...

3. Source: lifeandland.org
Link:https://www.lifeandland.org/2009/04/does-the-%E2%80%9Cthe-lost-shipwreck-of-paul%E2%80%9D-hold-water-or-have-the-anchors-from-the-apostle-paul%E2%80%99s-shipwreck-been-discovered-on-malta/

Source snippet

DOES THE “THE LOST SHIPWRECK OF PAUL” HOLD...Apr 22, 2009 — Mr. Cornuke claims to have found the only tangible remains from the shipwrec...

4. Source: aleteia.org
Title: The wreckage that made a nation: St
Link:https://aleteia.org/2025/02/10/the-wreckage-that-made-a-nation-st-pauls-shipwreck/

Source snippet

Paul's shipwreck - Aleteia10 Feb 2025 — Built in the 1570s, the church houses relics such as part of Paul's right wrist bone and a marble...

5. Source: holylandphotos.org
Link:https://holylandphotos.org/photos/MLVALLHA14

6. Source: biblearchaeology.org
Title: Thomas Bay (Acts 27:39)
Link:https://biblearchaeology.org/research-articles/does-the-lost-shipwreck-of-paul-hold-water/

Source snippet

Associates For Biblical ResearchDoes 'The Lost Shipwreck Of Paul' Hold Water?Cornuke claims to have found the only tangible remains from...

7. Source: independent.com.mt
Link:https://www.independent.com.mt/articles/2010-04-25/news/st-pauls-shipwreck-st-pauls-bay-or-st-thomas-bay-273614/

Source snippet

The Malta IndependentSt Paul's Shipwreck: St Paul's Bay or St Thomas Bay?25 Apr 2010 — According to Mr Cornuke, St Paul was shipwrecked i...

8. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Acts 27
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acts_27

9. Source: holylandphotos.wordpress.com
Title: In this temporary “home” 11 Anchor Stocks were collected.Read more
Link:https://holylandphotos.wordpress.com/2021/12/22/pauls-shipwreck-on-malta-anchor-stocks-part-1/

Source snippet

HolyLandPhotos' BlogPaul's Shipwreck on Malta: Anchor Stocks—Part 1Dec 22, 2021 — Temporary “home” for the Roman Anchor Stocks that are i...

10. Source: biblearchaeology.org
Link:https://biblearchaeology.org/research-articles/benedicts-anchor-was-it-from-the-shipwreck-of-the-apostle-paul-on-malta/

Source snippet

Paul's Grotto in the city of Rabat, he was shown an inscribed lead Roman anchor stock that had been discovered five years...Read more...

11. Source: sanctipauli.mt
Link:https://sanctipauli.mt/info-point/saint-pauls-shipwreck-collegiate-church-valletta/

12. Source: atlasobscura.com
Title: of shipwrecks and wristbones the story of st paul s remains
Link:https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/of-shipwrecks-and-wristbones-the-story-of-st-paul-s-remains

Additional References

13. Source: chalcedon.edu
Link:https://chalcedon.edu/resources/articles/anchors-from-apostle-pauls-shipwreck-presumed-found

14. Source: tripadvisor.ie
Link:https://www.tripadvisor.ie/Attraction_Review-g190328-d19092649-Reviews-Collegiate_Parish_Church_of_St_Paul_s_Shipwreck-Valletta_Island_of_Malta.html

15. Source: gpsmycity.com
Link:https://www.gpsmycity.com/attractions/church-of-st-pauls-shipwreck-28018.html

16. Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/oldroyalnavalcollege/posts/do-you-know-the-story-behind-the-altarpiece-in-the-chapel-this-striking-painting/1187964360211620/

17. Source: instagram.com
Link:https://www.instagram.com/reel/DT1LSpnjI7r/

18. Source: veryvalletta.com
Link:https://veryvalletta.com/points_of_interest/st-pauls-shipwreck-church/

19. Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/universityofmalta/posts/an-ancient-anchor-a-mysterious-inscription-and-a-legendary-shipwreck-could-this-/1033129505514792/

20. Source: visitmalta.com
Link:https://www.visitmalta.com/nl/blog/when-your-lifes-a-mess-think-of-st-pauls-shipwreck

21. Source: foxnews.com
Link:https://www.foxnews.com/science/biblical-shipwreck-discovery-anchor-from-st-pauls-shipwreck-identified-researchers-claim

22. Source: youtube.com
Title: Where was Paul shipwrecked on his way to Rome?
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dk-jHfF954M

Source snippet

Paul: Shipwrecked On Malta | Pentecost to Patmos...

Topic Tree

Follow this branch

Parent topic

Malta Mysteries

Related pages 2