How Were the Ik Branded as Selfish?

Introduction

The story of the Ik people of north-eastern Uganda is often presented as a cautionary tale about human selfishness. In reality, it has become a cautionary tale about anthropology itself. Colin Turnbull’s 1972 bestseller The Mountain People portrayed the Ik as a society in which generosity, family loyalty and cooperation had virtually disappeared. The book became internationally famous and helped create the enduring image of the Ik as “the most selfish people on earth”. Yet later research found that Turnbull had observed the community during an exceptional period of famine, displacement and social disruption, and that he mistook crisis behaviour for permanent culture.[Aeon]aeon.coWhy were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?Why were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?October 5, 2020 — 5 Oct 2020 — The evidence strongly indicates that the selfish…Published: October 5, 2020

The result was not a deliberate hoax in the usual sense of an invented fraud. Rather, it was a powerful misrepresentation that spread through popular culture, academia and journalism. For decades, a small Ugandan community carried a global reputation built on conclusions that many later researchers regarded as deeply flawed.[Berghahn Journals]berghahnjournals.comBerghahn Journals Telling Tales?in: Conflict and Society Volume…by D Rodgers · 2021 · Cited by 9 — Certainly, coming back to controversy surrounding The Mountain Peop…

The Claims That Made the Ik Internationally Famous

Turnbull conducted fieldwork among the Ik during the mid-1960s and published his findings in The Mountain People in 1972. His account described a society allegedly stripped of compassion. According to the book, parents neglected children, neighbours refused to help one another, the elderly were abandoned, and sharing was almost non-existent. Turnbull argued that extreme scarcity had transformed the Ik into a culture organised around ruthless individual survival.

Wikipedia

The book attracted enormous attention because it appeared to answer a much larger question: what happens when social bonds collapse? Turnbull did not merely describe hardship. He suggested that the Ik represented a fundamentally different kind of society, one in which cooperation itself had largely disappeared. His conclusions were dramatic enough that he even proposed dispersing the population into small groups and ending their existence as a distinct community.

Wikipedia

These claims travelled far beyond anthropology. The Ik became a symbol in debates about human nature, morality and individualism. Journalists, playwrights and commentators cited the book as evidence that social cooperation could vanish under pressure. A small Ugandan community was transformed into a global example of alleged human depravity.[The New York Review of Books]nybooks.comdancing with the moonThe New York Review of BooksDancing with the Moon | Kwame Anthony Appiah16 Nov 2000 — Yet The Mountain People ends with a polemic against…

How Famine and Weak Fieldwork Distorted the Portrait

The central problem identified by later critics was that Turnbull studied the Ik during an extraordinary crisis rather than ordinary life. The region was experiencing severe drought, food shortages and social upheaval. The Ik had also suffered displacement from traditional hunting territories, forcing difficult adaptations to new economic conditions.[Aeon]aeon.coWhy were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?Why were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?October 5, 2020 — 5 Oct 2020 — The evidence strongly indicates that the selfish…Published: October 5, 2020

Wikipedia

Subsequent researchers argued that behaviour observed during famine should not automatically be treated as evidence of normal cultural values. Famines frequently produce desperate actions across many societies. People who are starving may act in ways that differ sharply from how they behave during more stable periods. Later assessments concluded that Turnbull largely failed to separate emergency conditions from long-term social patterns.[Aeon]aeon.coWhy were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?Why were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?October 5, 2020 — 5 Oct 2020 — The evidence strongly indicates that the selfish…Published: October 5, 2020[Science 2.0]science20.comSource details in endnotes.

Critics also questioned aspects of his field methods. Anthropologist Bernd Heine, who later carried out extensive research among the Ik, argued that Turnbull’s knowledge of the language and local traditions was limited and that many of his conclusions rested on inadequate foundations. Heine concluded that the portrait presented in The Mountain People was seriously misleading.

Wikipedia

Another criticism concerned sources. Later discussions suggested that Turnbull relied heavily on accounts from elderly informants describing a contrast between remembered earlier conditions and the severe crisis they were experiencing at the time. This may have encouraged him to interpret temporary social breakdown as evidence of a deeper cultural transformation.

Wikipedia

The book’s dramatic narrative also created a methodological risk. Extreme examples attract attention, but they can encourage researchers to emphasise the most shocking observations while overlooking contradictory evidence. Critics argued that the Ik were presented less as a complex community and more as a moral lesson about the collapse of society.[Berghahn Journals]berghahnjournals.comBerghahn Journals Telling Tales?in: Conflict and Society Volume…by D Rodgers · 2021 · Cited by 9 — Certainly, coming back to controversy surrounding The Mountain Peop…

What Later Research Found About Sharing and Social Life

The strongest challenge to Turnbull’s reputation came from researchers who spent time with the Ik after the famine years had passed. Their findings did not support the idea that selfishness was the defining feature of Ik culture. Instead, they documented cooperation, social obligations, family ties and patterns of sharing that looked much more like those found in many other small-scale communities.

Wikipedia

Research published in the twenty-first century provided particularly direct evidence. Studies examining generosity among the Ik found substantial willingness to share resources with others. Rather than behaving as an exceptionally selfish society, the Ik displayed levels of cooperation inconsistent with Turnbull’s famous portrayal. Researchers concluded that his observations reflected the effects of severe scarcity rather than a permanent cultural norm.[PMC]pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govPMCGenerosity among the Ik of UgandaPMCGenerosity among the Ik of Uganda[Rutgers University]rutgers.eduugandas ik are not unbelievably selfish and meanugandas ik are not unbelievably selfish and mean

Modern work with Ik elders has also revealed frustration with the international image created by The Mountain People. Community members have challenged the idea that the book accurately represented their society and questioned why one outsider’s observations during a crisis came to define how the world viewed them.[ResearchGate]researchgate.netSource details in endnotes.

The contrast is striking. Turnbull’s account described a people who allegedly lacked generosity. Later empirical studies specifically measuring generosity found evidence of sharing and cooperation. The newer research does not claim that the Ik are uniquely virtuous; rather, it suggests they are a normal human community whose reputation was distorted by observations made during exceptional circumstances.[PMC]pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govPMCGenerosity among the Ik of UgandaPMCGenerosity among the Ik of Uganda[ScienceAlert]sciencealert.comExcept there are researchers who now think that reputation is wholly undeserved…

Why the Story Still Matters

The Ik controversy remains one of the most discussed cases in African anthropology because it illustrates how a powerful narrative can outlive the evidence that supported it. Once the image of the Ik as extraordinarily selfish entered public consciousness, it continued to circulate in books, articles and classrooms long after substantial criticism emerged.[Berghahn Journals]berghahnjournals.comBerghahn Journals Telling Tales?in: Conflict and Society Volume…by D Rodgers · 2021 · Cited by 9 — Certainly, coming back to controversy surrounding The Mountain Peop…

For Uganda’s history of contested truth, the episode is important because it shows that damaging myths do not always arise from deliberate fraud. Sometimes they emerge from sincere but flawed interpretation, amplified by a compelling story. Turnbull’s book was influential precisely because it appeared to reveal something profound about human nature. Later research suggested that it mostly revealed what famine can do to human behaviour—and how easily observers can mistake a crisis for a culture.[Aeon]aeon.coWhy were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?Why were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?October 5, 2020 — 5 Oct 2020 — The evidence strongly indicates that the selfish…Published: October 5, 2020[Science 2.0]science20.comSource details in endnotes.

The enduring lesson is not that the Ik were uniquely misunderstood, but that extraordinary claims about entire peoples require extraordinary evidence. In the case of the Ik, decades of subsequent research indicate that one of the most famous anthropological portraits of the twentieth century captured a moment of desperation rather than the character of a society.[Aeon]aeon.coWhy were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?Why were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?October 5, 2020 — 5 Oct 2020 — The evidence strongly indicates that the selfish…Published: October 5, 2020[PMC]pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govPMCGenerosity among the Ik of UgandaPMCGenerosity among the Ik of Uganda

Amazon book picks

Further Reading

Books and field guides related to How Were the Ik Branded as Selfish?. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.

Book

Factfulness

By Hans Rosling, Ola Rosling et al.

Addresses how dramatic narratives can mislead.

See on Amazon

Book

The Art of Not Being Governed

By James C. Scott

Provides broader perspective on marginalized communities.

See on Amazon

Book

The Innocent Anthropologist

By Nigel Barley

Offers insight into fieldwork challenges and interpretation.

See on Amazon

Book

The mountain people

By Colin M. Turnbull

First published 1972. Subjects: $7.95 0, Africa, Anomy, Ethnology, Ik (African people).

See on Amazon

Browse more on Amazon:FactfulnessThe Art of Not Being GovernedThe Innocent Anthropologist

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

eBay marketplace picks

Marketplace Samples

Live-tested eBay searches with available results related to this page.

Shop location

UsingUSA USA USAUKCanadaAustraliaIreland

Example eBay listing

Hand Carved Ethiopian Afar Headrest Wooden Tribal Ethnographic Collectible

SearcheBay.co.uk: ethnographic collectible

Browse similar oneBay.co.uk

Example eBay listing

Old Tribal Wooden Mask Hand Carved Painted Ethnographic Collectible Vintage Art

SearcheBay.co.uk: ethnographic collectible

Browse similar oneBay.co.uk

Example eBay listing

Vintage Chinese Lotus Shoes Hand Painted Leather Ethnographic Collectible Pair

SearcheBay.co.uk: ethnographic collectible

Browse similar oneBay.co.uk

Browse more oneBay.co.uk

Example items shown for inspiration; availability and pricing can change. Branchoria may earn a commission if you purchase through outbound eBay links.

Endnotes

1. Source: aeon.co
Title: Why were the Ik people vilified as selfish and nasty?
Link:https://aeon.co/essays/why-were-the-ik-people-vilified-as-selfish-and-nasty

Published: October 5, 2020

2. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Ik people
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ik_people

3. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Colin Turnbull
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colin_Turnbull

4. Source: science20.com
Link:https://science20.com/news_staff/the_ik_people_of_mountain_uganda_are_not_as_selfish_and_loveless_as_1960s_anthropologists_claimed-249586

5. Source: sciencealert.com
Link:https://www.sciencealert.com/anthropologists-return-to-a-selfish-tribe-in-uganda-and-find-they-re-actually-decent-folk

6. Source: pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Title: PMCGenerosity among the Ik of Uganda
Link:https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10427480/

7. Source: rutgers.edu
Title: ugandas ik are not unbelievably selfish and mean
Link:https://www.rutgers.edu/news/ugandas-ik-are-not-unbelievably-selfish-and-mean

8. Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/302977829_Understanding_Hunger_with_Ik_Elders_and_Turnbull%27s_The_Mountain_People

9. Source: Wikipedia
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ikland

10. Source: berghahnjournals.com
Title: Berghahn Journals Telling Tales?
Link:https://www.berghahnjournals.com/view/journals/conflict-and-society/7/1/arcs070108.xml

11. Source: nybooks.com
Title: dancing with the moon
Link:https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2000/11/16/dancing-with-the-moon/

12. Source: jstor.org
Link:https://www.jstor.org/stable/26410169

Additional References

13. Source: humanjourney.us
Link:https://humanjourney.us/book-reviews/the-mountain-people-colin-turnbull/

14. Source: youtube.com
Title: The Ik people of Kidepo Valley National park,Uganda
Link:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcwuCqGoFTA

15. Source: youtube.com
Link:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rq7oXjeXT6w

16. Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/BBCRadio4/posts/controversial-anthropologist-colin-turnbull-thought-he-had-found-the-most-selfis/10164751977505459/

17. Source: humangenerosity.org
Link:https://www.humangenerosity.org/hgp-members-find-that-contrary-to-prior-claims-the-ik-people-of-uganda-are-generous-and-cooperative/

18. Source: youtube.com
Title: Uganda’s mountain community seeks sustainability
Link:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TqvycRIAWK4

19. Source: wp.lancs.ac.uk
Title: 14 Lazarus
Link:https://wp.lancs.ac.uk/good-culture/files/2018/01/14-Lazarus.pdf

20. Source: youtube.com
Title: The IK: Uganda’s little known tribe
Link:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6i5CFjMvpQI

21. Source: youtube.com
Title: Ik Dispatch: Ik community fights to maintain a distinct identity
Link:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDuXbMShlEI

22. Source: ssoar.info
Title: ssoar ethnoscripts 2023 1 meinert Sharing Land Sharing Faith Ground
Link:https://www.ssoar.info/ssoar/bitstream/handle/document/93452/ssoar-ethnoscripts-2023-1-meinert-Sharing_Land_Sharing_Faith_Ground.pdf?sequence=1